Guideline 10: Foster inclusive participation
Guidance to foster inclusive and equitable student participation that supports the development of language based on students’ needs
Specifications for Guideline 10
Specification 10A
Materials present a balance of independent, paired, small-group, and whole-class activities.
Specification 10B
Flexible grouping structures are recommended to enhance student learning and language development (e.g., heterogeneous groups, home language groups, groups by level, etc.).
Specification 10C
Teacher materials give guidance on what to look for, listen for, questions to ask, how to monitor for equity and/or feedback to give when meeting with students individually or in small groups.
Specification 10D
Materials provide consistent and sustainable norms, routines, and/or monitoring tools to promote and reflect on equitable participation.
Guideline 11: Provide supports as-needed
Guidance for providing as-needed supports to address potential language demands and opportunities in a way that amplifies rather than simplifies language for sensemaking
Specifications for Guideline 11
Specification 11A
Materials include activities that provide students with multiple entry points and multiple ways to express and represent their understanding.
Specification 11B
Teacher materials identify possible language demands and opportunities (e.g., passive voice, nominalization, technical vocabulary, science-specific language functions, graphs and models, etc.).
Specification 11C
Materials amplify (rather than simplify) language by providing a variety of support for students with different linguistic strengths and needs (e.g., language routines, discussion protocols, sentence frames, etc.).
Specification 11D
Supports are embedded throughout both student and teacher materials rather than as an add-on (e.g., “For MLLs” call-out boxes).
Guideline 12: Gradually decrease use of supports
Guidance for implementing and gradually decreasing the use of supports for language development
Specifications for Guideline 12
Specification 12A
Materials consistently provide access to cognitively demanding tasks, and guidance is provided for when and how to use supports to encourage productive struggle before intervening.
Specification 12B
Materials help teachers understand the progression of particular skills and gradually decrease supports for students to gain independence in tackling rigorous tasks.
Specification 12C
Materials provide guidance on how to modify supports according to students’ strengths and needs.